Follow
Share
Yes.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to sp196902
Report

Absolutely Yes...why would anyone think it was not fair.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to lkdrymom
Report
SharShar Jun 26, 2024
I guess I feel like I owe her
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Hi SharShar - I'll put it this way ....I think it's UNFAIR for a parent to actually think otherwise. To feel so entitled as to think that they shouldn't have planned for their senior years, and if one of their children is so thoughtful and selfless in taking them into their home and take care of them, then absolutely, it is Beyond Fair to pay them. There's consideration of rent/care/food, etc.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Hopeforhelp22
Report
SharShar Jun 26, 2024
Thank you for that, I guess I’m feeling a little guilty
(0)
Report
See 3 more replies
What about tax? That's a different issue from 'fair' (and yes of course it's fair - why should it be free). I think that sharing out-of-pocket costs (food, power, etc) isn’t hypothetical ‘income’, for tax purposes, but I’m not sure about the charge for care. I hope someone with more knowledge of USA tax will chime in here. Also about Medicare – you may need to document this some way that it doesn’t look as though M is ‘gifting’ you the money, just in case she needs Medicaid in the future.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

ALL household expenses should be divided. If there are 3 adults then ALL the expenses get divided by 3. If it is a husband, wife and 3 kids and mom moves in then the expenses get divided by 6 and m om pays 1/6 or all expenses.
AND if mom is in need of a caregiver and you take on that role then you get paid for the care that you give.
All this should be worked out and agreed upon BEFORE mom moves in. And there should be a WRITTEN agreement for both the expenses and for caregiving.

Oh, by ALL household expenses I am also talking about Insurance, property taxes, mortgage, water, sewer, garbage, newspaper, cable. And if you go on vacation mom pays for Respite stay in a local facility or pays for an increase of caregivers for the time you are gone.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

You don't owe your mother anything. Take her in only if you want to, otherwise, resentment builds from feeling obligated. Parents have children because we want them....its our privilege and or job to care for them and raise them to be productive citizens of society. As parents, it's also our job to plan for old age, to save $$$, etc. So of course it's ok and standard to charge rent to your mom. If 4 people live in your home, mom would pay 1/4 of the monthly bills. You can also add on more for caregiving.

Wishing you the best of luck with all of this.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

When you turn 50, you quit paid work & the grown child of your choosing must take you in. Provide your housing, cook for you (only meals you like) drive you everywhere & keep you entertained. Of course pay for everything! The parent spent their time & money on that child for 20 or so years. An investment - this allows them to live for free and have their grown children as servants later. This is how it is.

PS This is what my friend's Mother told him - all his life.

These long held views caused him much guilt & grief.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Beatty
Report
MargaretMcKen Jun 27, 2024
It's a pity that children can't say 'that's bullsh*t, Ma'.
(3)
Report
My tale below was just to show how beliefs can differ, especially across generations. Cultures too.

I personally think it is fair for an adult to pay their way. Housing, bills, food, medicine all cost. It may be hard to calculate 'care' costs, but hopefully you can find a suitable amount that seems fair.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Beatty
Report

Absolutely it is, at the very least parent should be paying fair market rent. Think about it for a moment, where else is her money going to go to?
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to mstrbill
Report

My Mom lives in the house next to us, which she sold to us at FMV. We charge her only what it costs to own and maintain the house (prop taxes, insurance, utilities, etc) so we don't profit off of her. She gets a rent invoice from me every month that line items what her rent pays for. If we were renting to a stranger we'd be getting twice to 3x the amount in rent.

I also grocery shop for her and make at least 60% of her meals so I have a separate monthly withdrawal for her share of groceries. Her SS barely covers any of this but she doesn't have many other expenses or needs anymore at 95.

I am basically her on-call caregiver (and now chauffer) who allows her to live semi-independently and comfortably in her home.

This plus, the cost of living nowadays, is necessary and more than fair.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

I see no problem in what you are doing.

I spent none of my own money on my mother until she was on Medicaid. She did live with me for 20 months but she had a house, for sale, that needed to be maintained. Her SS went for that. Her small pension of $200 a month, went to what she needed thru the month. I never felt guilty for using her money on her. Thats what its there for.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

I don't charge anything but I do let her purchase the groceries. I do all the cooking. She pays for her medicines and personal items in most cases. She pays for an aide when we have one. This seems fair to me for now.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Silverspring
Report

Fair would be that she pays her fair share of all household expenses. Gas, electric, mortgage, property taxes, cable, food....EVERYTHING.
If there are 3 people living in the house she would pay 1/3 of all expenses.

And...adding to that if you are doing HANDS ON caregiving tasks she should be paying you for that as well in addition to household expenses. (check your area for the hourly rate for caregivers you will probably find that the rate is between $25 and $40 per hour)

If she were living anywhere else she would have to pay these very same expenses.
She would have to pay for a caregiver as well.

Proof of any payments to you that these payments are for her expenses both household and personal caregiving expenses takes it out of the realm of a "gift" to you so that if there is ever a need to apply for Medicaid there is no question that the money paid to you is for living expenses and caregiving.

I would never expect any family member to take me in and give me "free food, housing and caregiving" without proper compensation. Actually I would NEVER put family in the position to care for me, it just is not fair to them.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

Yes. I'm now living here with my Dad 24/7 as his caregiver. He's 96 - I'll be 68 next month. When it became obvious Dad needed 24/7 care - he has moderate Lewy Body Dementia, I had my Son - who was staying here caring for Dad - swap homes with me so that I could come and stay here with Dad. I don't pay Dad rent to live here to care for him. I have my own home and mortgage I'm already paying for - Dad's home has long since been paid for, so I don't feel I need to pay my Dad rent to be here caring for him, but I do pitch in my share of household expenses, goods/food, etc. This was all agreed upon with my Dad and my older brother. (No one else can or wants to be here 24/7 with Dad - he's a handful lol)
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Mamacrow
Report
Grandma1954 Jul 11, 2024
But dad should be paying YOU to care for him
(2)
Report
Of course a parent should pay their own way . You should not be supporting your parent . You should not be spending your own money on your parent . The parent should be paying for groceries , their share of utilities , and for your services.
And possibly rent .

It should not cost you a dime . If you quit your job , that is costing you .

There is a stigma about taking money from an elderly parent. When my father in law wanted a smart phone , my DH added him to our plan but made his Dad pay the $50 monthly increase to our bill .
DH caught a lot of grief for that . People thought it was petty and cheap and how could you take the $50 from him . The old man had more money than us . Why would I pay for his phone ?

I don’t understand why people thought we should pay for his phone service . The phone itself was “ free “ when adding it to our service plan for 3 years . Father in law got a good deal .

PS father in law died . We are stuck now paying his $50 a month for the next two years anyway.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to waytomisery
Report

Even the poorest of parents usually have a small income, why should they bank that money and accumulate wealth while their caregivers are burdened with extra costs?
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to cwillie
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter