Follow
Share

My mom is on Aricept and Namenda for uncomplicated senile dementia and has been on these two drugs for 12 years. My mom is 92. Overall her health is good. A small dose of Lopressor for the heart. Had a cardiologist appointment went well he does not want to see her for 6 months. My mom's mind is good except for vision and hearing. The facility wants to put her in Memory Care. I do not feel this is appropriate for her at this time. My mom has even stated if I go there I may as well die.
I think this facility is doing this for financial reasons. I do have a Neurologist appointment for her coming up. In the meantime, the facility wants to get a Speech therapist to do a cognitive test. I have looked at the test of questions. With her macular degeneration, she wouldn't pass. She is out of sight but not out of mind.


I am a 34+ BSN nurse. I am a case manager in the hospital. I think this is not right. Has anybody ever dealt with issues like this with a parent?

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
What is mom doing, or not doing that the AL thinks she would be safer in Memory Care?
Is she needing more help that they have not informed you about?
Has she gotten lost within the facility or needed help navigating around the facility that they have not mentioned?
Is she needing more help with ADL's?

I don't think, and I am not a professional but,... a Speech Therapist would be qualified to give a cognitive test. That would be a job for a Neurologist or a Neuropsychologist. And a good one would take into consideration the vision problems and hearing problems that your mom has.
You do mention in your profile that your mom has Alzheimer's / Dementia. If that is an actual diagnosis I doubt another cognitive test would reveal any more.

With the diagnosis of Alzheimer's/Dementia moving her to MC is a good option. It is possible that he is needing more help and with AL they may not do 2 person transfer, or they may not be able to use equipment where in MC they might be able to use equipment and have the ability to do 2 person transfers.

I would request a meeting and have them detail exactly why they are suggesting this transfer.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

A speech therapist IS qualified to do some types of cognitive testing. Mine did testing with me. A Speech Language Therapist deals with many aspects of cognitive functioning because the ability to think of words, identify objects, and speak them are related. You may notice that people with cognitive impairments may develop issues with misnaming things. For example maybe a horse is called a dog. Four legs and a tail, right? There are numerous cognitive exercises to do just as there physical exercises for the body. The SLT also works with the patient on the physical aspects of swallowing and speech. Which all reminds me, I should be doing my homework more!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
igloo572 Oct 2021
Yes! My mom had a ST do an eval on her. It was part of the team approach her gerontology group did. She had scar tissue in her throat which affected swallowing.

But one very important thing I hadn’t thought about that they (ST) were keyed in to notice was “code switching” on language and for having allowances on testing done to accommodate it.
That for those, like my mom, who’s first language was not English & fluently bilingual her whole 99 yr life, is that they tend to revert back to the 1st language as their dementia increases. So there are processing issues in answering questions in English whether spoken or written. If the tester is not aware of the elders background, they can take the hesitation or silence as not being cognitive, not understanding. Doing a mini mental & saying “Table, chair, pencil” when the elder instinctively and initially thinks “la mesa, la silla, el lapiz”, flat requires extra time to code switch. If this at all could be your parent, try to see if this at all could be happening for their cognition.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
Loss of vision in one eye shouldn't cause significant visual impairment.

If she has been on medication for dementia for over a decade she either never progressed beyond MCI (and many people don't) or she is well beyond the early stages of dementia, but I agree with Grandma1954 that I would want to know exactly what they are seeing as causing problems in her current placement and why they feel she needs memory care.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
DrBenshir Nov 2021
Not true! There is probably some AMD in the other eye but it has not advanced as much. Also, there is a significant neurological link between the two eyes, and between vision and hearing. If that isn't enough, poor binocular vision can impact all bilateral sensory and motor processing.
(0)
Report
"My mom's mind is good except for vision and hearing"

But you say she has been taking meds for 12 years for uncomplicated senile dementia. This means she has cognitive problems.

This is how I look at MC based on the AL/MC in my small area. They are a step up from an AL. This is for people who really need more care and supervision. Those who are really into Dementia. The person is now in lockdown and there may be a better ratio of aides to residents. A RN is in charge but mostly aides doing the care. Is it the RN that is telling u Mom needs a Speech Therapist?

Seems Mom knows what is going on. I would first ask why they think she needs to be changed over. (I too think money could be involved) Has she become aggressive. Does she need to be watched more? My Moms AL did everything for her but they did not separate their residents. They bathed and dressed her. Changed her. Made sure she got to meals. She could still feed herself. She used a walker. Tell them Mom has a appt with her Neurologist and that you will talk over their concerns with him/her. You will see if he/she feels a Speech Therapist is needed.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My uncle was in nursing home and they recommended MC. I didn’t agree. I was visiting everyday for a half hour or so. At their recommendation I spent a day with him. It became very apparent to me why he needed to be moved. He’s now in Memory Care for two weeks and has adjusted well.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Someone we see everyday--we don't notice the little, slow slippage of skills-cognition, vision, etc.

I don't see my mom everyday. Not even every week. Maybe once a month, and I am VERY aware of her sliding down, so to speak. YB, with whom she lives, doesn't notice and therefore doesn't address any issues.

Fair to him, there isn't much, if anything he could do differently. I wish he would take her to be checked out when she falls (which she is doing more frequently) but he refuses.

Looking at your mom with fresh eyes---no pre-conceived ideas about what you already know--and maybe you'll have an AHA moment when you see she does need a step up in care. Or maybe you'll be more convinced that she doesn't.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

My dad is legally blind - macular degeneration and glaucoma in one eye and totally blind (not even light/dark) in the other. He actually managed to complete the test with the drawings of the clock etc because the person administering the test knew that his sight was limited and didn't expect a perfect drawing; she just expected him to be able to show some logical effort and an ability to tell her what it should look like. Most of the test did not involve sight so he aced it - even with very limited short-term memory (but he did count backwards by 7's so long he had to be told to stop!) My dad's sight has continued to deteriorate, as has his hearing and memory but he is still in assisted living. He did get off the elevator a few times on the wrong floor and got turned around but someone always got him back to his apartment without incident. I have increased some of the services he receives so he gets more "cues' to go to lunch and dinner. He's over 100 years old and isn't terribly interested in social activities every day and is mostly content to sit in his comfortable chair with the tv on and dozing. Getting himself to social activities is his responsiblity and in Memory Care they would make certain he was involved in more activities and had more interaction outside his apartment. Your mom may actually benefit from Memory Care if she is having difficulty participating in the community due to her increasing dementia and loss of sight.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

abkinder, I remember when my Dad was living in Independent Living at a senior facility that the Staff called me into a meeting. They said it was time to move Dad over to their Memory Care section. That caught me totally by surprised because whenever I visited Dad, he seemed pretty sharp to me. Apparently he was "show-boating" where he appears to be in clear mind.

When I told Dad's private caregiver that the Staff wanted Dad to move, she agreed. She said my Dad was getting confused. I told Dad he was moving to another section where the apartment will be much smaller [instead of a suite, he will have one room w/bath], and I did a therapeutic fib by saying the monthly rent would be a lot cheaper. He liked hearing that !! We joked about his "college dorm room". Now he had a village looking after him,

Dad was now in a safer environment as the Staff said they caught Dad trying to leave the building at night, but now in Memory Care, the elevator shuts down [unless one has a code] so the residents don't start to wander. Even the building front door is locked earlier then at the other building [coded]. During the day, there is a Staff member at the front desk making sure a resident doesn't leave by themselves.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

No no and no.
My Mom fell in AL and as a result they made her go to MC. I had my own caregivers there 10 hours a day and AL and MC were like night and day. And not in a good way.

When Mom was in AL she ate in the Dining room and could go to the exercise classes. She was stimulated. Laughed and talked with others. She didn’t make a lot of sense but people enjoyed her.

I did get the snobby old people who said she didn’t belong in AL and she probably didn’t, but she thrived there. Once they moved her, if I didn’t have my own people there, she would have died. They basically did nothing with them. Sat them all in one area in front of a TV.

My Mom also had macular degeneration in both eyes. She got the shots to keep it from getting worse but eventually it stabilized and we quit the shots.

I ended up getting 24 care and moved my Mom home. It was more stressful and difficult for me, but cheaper and better for her. If I could have left her in AL, I might have stayed but once I saw how they operated in MC I knew I had to leave. There was less care in MC, but the cost was much higher.

You might ask them if you hired some private care for her during the day could you keep her in AL. That was how I was able to keep my Mom in AL until the fall. Keep in mind once the fall occurred, my Mom could no longer walk.

Overall, I agree with your Mom. From my experience she’s right. No one really knows what goes on in these places, but I did because I had people there 10 hours a day and it was eye opening.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
disgustedtoo Nov 2021
Experience with one place does not define 100% of the MC facilities.

My mother's place was often a hive of activity. They had special projects, brought in outside entertainment, depending on desire and ability they had outside activities/trips.

No, I wasn't there all day every day, but my visits were random days/hours, so they couldn't plan something to just pretend with me. When I did visit, it was usually for a good long time, so I could observe different staff and different times of day (mornings, afternoons, evenings.)

There are several others on this forum who are also very pleased with their MC facility.

I've always maintained that we who advocate need to CHECK the facilities as best we can (obviously the virus impact our ability to do that, but before and after, there's NO excuse not to thoroughly vet a place you plan to house a LO. As with my visits, make them random, hit various days and times, chat with others (residents, family members, maybe staff), use all FIVE senses in your "observations."

Clearly the place your mother was in was NOT one we would recommend. A few visits, different times of the day before the move would have made the situation clear, without needing to hire others for 10 hr/day on top of the higher cost of MC.
(1)
Report
Interesting that her vision problem is only in one eye. My grandparents had and mom has macular degeneration. There are glasses that can help her to see better. She will never completely lose her vision but will lose her central vision. With her hearing, she needs to wear her hearing aides in order to continue being able to hear. Not wearing her hearing aides leads to permanent deafness if the nerves are not stimulated regularly.

A speech therapist is not the right person to do cognition testing. That would be a neurologist. Advise the facility that you will discuss your mom's placement after receiving results from her neurologist. Be aware that medications for Alzheimer's type dementia work in the earlier stages but tend to not work in latter stages. That happened to my grandfather. He also had hearing and vision problems. Try hard to get her vision and hearing addressed since folks that lose those abilities decline faster.

Use those good nursing skills for your mom's best health care. You are her best advocate (coming from an RN with BSN too).
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

From what you're telling us, that's absurd! Of course, it's not right. I suggest that you immediately contact both APS and the Ombudsman in your state.

Stand your ground for your mom!
Remind management of the ADA act and "Residents' Rights" -
If all else fails, contact the ACLU because this is a civil rights issue.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
disgustedtoo Nov 2021
Getting more detail would be better for decision making at this point, both for OP AND for us. From the little posted, we/OP can't really assess mom's needs. As several others noted, sometimes we can't see the forest for the trees. Chatting on the phone or visits don't always reveal subtle declines, as others noted.

OP would be better advised to keep her plan for see the neurologist, but get more information from the staff as to why they feel mom needs to move. What declines have they observed that OP might not see? Neither of my brothers could see/sense the change in mom (she was living in her own place at that time.) Sometimes they can pull up their socks and "appear" more normal for periods of time.

If OP can get more input from the staff, she can address these with the neurologist. If there's anything she can share here, it might help us make better informed suggestions/recommendations. Running off right away to complain isn't helping mom or really addressing the situation. Mom isn't being abused, They "want" mom to move, but they can't force it, so what's the rush to get APS, etc involved?
(1)
Report
What is the facility's evidence that your mother needs Memory Care? If your mother needs additional help, can you hire some extra private help?

If the facility is trying to move her with insufficient cause, be shopping for another facility.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Agreeing with VegasLady and Igloo572. I'd ask the speech therapist about what modifications they plan to use with your mom's vision problem. Between that test and the neurologist's exam, y'all should be able to evaluate what is best for her. You may wish to give the neurologist's office advanced notice as the appointment may take a bit longer.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

It is appropriate to give her a memory test, and it is appropriate to do so verbally, because of her eyesight. Once you have that information, you can make an informed decision about whether or not Memory Care is the right place.
I can imagine that if she's been living in a facility for 12 years, it may be hard for you to see or perceive changes in her cognitive abilities. Memory Care is not a death sentence, it is a place where seniors go who cannot remember things and need a safe environment.
Every change is not necessarily money driven. Only you can tell (us) if this facility is honest or not-- she's lived there for 12 years so it would seem that you trust them.
With my mom, it was very evident that she was doing successively worse on the memory tests but that you couldn't necessarily tell, from the outside, that she was losing brain power.
Again, I don't understand equating Memory Care with " I will die ". Does she have a geriatrician? They can help you figure out next best steps.
Wishing you luck. All of these transitions are hard and fraught. They may be harder for us than for them.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
disgustedtoo Nov 2021
Thank you for a sensible response.

Of course some (like this mother) think ANY change, NH, MC, etc is going to be the death of them. Despite having AL in her own plans, my mother refused to even consider one after dementia came calling - you'd think it was a dirt, snake-filled hovel the way she spat out the words!

Although tests might reveal some reduction in cognition, even that isn't what should be a deciding factor. Can't draw a clock? So what? Does drawing a clock have anything to do with being able to live somewhat independently? Nope. Those tests can be helpful, but some people can do just fine "independently" longer than others.

I think OP would be better served to:
1) get more detail from staff as to why they recommend the move
2) once you have input from #1, spend a whole day with her

Sometimes we don't see the changes that do lead one to need more supervision. We are not there all day every day, like the staff is. Spend several days, if possible, at different times. She may do find during your visits, chats, etc, but dealing with the stresses of everyday life, she may be exhibiting struggles with some activities which may indicate the need for more supervision.

My mother had both Macular Degeneration and hearing loss. I agree with another person, get her to wear the hearing aides as much as possible! Sadly my mother had already lost hearing in one ear (surgically correctable when detected, but she refused) and with dementia it was getting difficult to keep the batteries fresh AND get her to keep it in. The loss will accelerate and will also impact cognition. She started treatments for the MD, considered legally blind in the first eye. I helped her before and after the move to MC. With hearing loss, it was important to protect her eyesight. Treatment was continued 4x/year until she had a stroke. Between the wheelchair she was already in, dementia and then the stroke it would have been difficult to get through the whole process. I don't think the MD had any real impact on her dementia. The hearing loss likely played a part, but high BP, even treated with meds, for many years likely lead to her vascular dementia (never tested, but given condition, age and progression, this is the most likely.)

Get more input from staff - ask for details, times of day, etc and then observe for yourself. Spend some whole days with her. As others noted, it might be illuminating.

As for if/when MC is needed, do spend time checking the facility, even the one associated with her current AL. Just because the AL was great doesn't always transfer to the MC area.
(1)
Report
If your mom's mind is good then I wouldn't agree to it. Having macular degeneration shouldn't be a reason to place her in memory care. My mom (95) is blind in one eye (prosthetic) and has AMD in the other - only has 15% vision. She, too is also hard of hearing. She is in a residential assisted living, but not a memory care unit. Can I say she doesn't get confused once in a while?? Heck no. But for the most part she knows whats going on. Knows her kids, grandkids and basically what to do for herself - she just needs help doing it. Stick to your guns, you know mom better than anyone. Good luck!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

You said she has dementia and can't see and can't hear. Given these facts and being 92, it makes sense to me to put her into memory care. They are trained to take care of people more so the the aides in assisted living. Would you at least consider that?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
disgustedtoo Nov 2021
NEVER did OP say mom was blind and deaf. There's a HUGE difference between having hearing loss and Macular Degeneration.

Also, just "having" dementia doesn't mean someone is ready for the MC unit. MC is for people who have MEMORY issues. The answer and focus here should be on what does the staff see/know about mom and her ability to get through the day in AL. With that information, OP should spend a day, many WHOLE days with mom, to see for herself how well mom manages.

Even the testing isn't and shouldn't be the deciding factor. Tests can document decline, but if someone can take care of themselves with minimal assistance, despite mild dementia, some hearing loss and some eyesight loss, then they don't need MC.

FYI: My mother's eyesight in one eye was seriously impacted by MD (something like 20/200), but they never said anything about taking her license away. Blind? Hardly. No different than someone who has lost an eye. Doesn't make them ready for a rubber room, does it? Even my former MIL managed to keep her license after losing eyesight in one eye. LOSING the eyesight in that eye, not poor vision from MD.
(1)
Report
I agree: don't move her unless Mom will benefit. And yes, her sensory impairments will impact her cognitive testing. I do not expect SLPs to understand vision impairments; they are not taught about this so why should they? If you know what Mom wants and needs stick with that.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Yes, you should have a meeting with the management to find out exactly why they are suggesting this, and also the financial implications both for you and for them. I would also take someone knowledgeable with you to the meeting, both for the questions and also to remember things afterwards. It may be justified, or it may be that they have more MC beds available and would get paid more.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

The first line of your post says your mother is on 2 medications for 'uncomplicated senile dementia' for 12 years. I haven't heard the word 'senile' used since my grandmother's days, but I digress. You then go on to say her mind is good. With dementia in force for 12 years, how exactly is her 'mind good'? A diagnosis of dementia means her mind is compromised; not 'gone', but impaired.

Furthermore, a cognitive exam has little to do with vision and everything to do with memory questions; only at the end do they ask the person to draw a clock to see where their executive brain function is at, the rest of it is verbal. My mother has horrendous hearing & macular degeneration herself, has taken the MoCA cognition exam at least 10x and the first time she scored an 18 out of 30, declining over the years to a 10. Her hearing and vision had nothing to do with her score; it was her cognitive decline and dementia that led to her scores and her eventual placement in Memory Care 3 years later. Bad hearing and vision does contribute to developing dementia to begin with, however, because all the 5 senses play a role in cognition. Your mother would only face issues if given a written test; normally the MoCA test is what's given which, like I said, is 95% verbal.

Going into Memory Care AL is by no means a 'death sentence'; just another stigma attached to a higher level of care that's often warranted for a person with your mother's conditions; dementia, poor eyesight, poor hearing and a heart condition. A person does not have to be 'out of their mind' to live in Memory Care; they just have to have dementia and require a smaller environment with less decisions to make in general, and a higher caregiver to resident ratio so their needs can be better seen to. My mother plays games and socializes with the other residents & friends she's made in her MC on a daily basis! So she's not 'out of her mind' and drooling in the corner, as some people would believe the environment to be in MC, like some insane asylum of the 1800s!

At some point, your mother will have to take a cognition exam, even if you want to move her out of this ALF and into another. My mother moved from regular AL into MC in 2019 when her dementia was moderate; she's now advanced and I'm seriously glad she's where she is b/c she suddenly requires a boat load of care which is available to her in MC, thank God.

If you feel that the AL is trying to swindle you by saying your mother requires more care in MC, then by all means, look around for another AL. But be prepared for the new facility to want her tested there before entry. It's the way things are done in managed care these days.

Whatever you decide to do, good luck.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
disgustedtoo Nov 2021
Everything you said and then some!

Tests are tests and some have really no bearing on one's ability to do ADLs or get through the day safely.

We don't know what the facility sees that may impact their recommendation to move. It isn't clear if OP has any details either - perhaps she didn't share them, but that is what is more important before making this decision. The hearing and eyesight issues make life more challenging (my mother also had both, along with medically treated high BP), and can impact progression of dementia, but they, in and of themselves, are not the deciding factors.

If OP doesn't have details regarding this recommendation, she should get them - difficulties mom might be having, time of day, etc. OP should also find a way to spend whole days with mom. Even with more moderate dementia, many can hold their own and seem to be of good mind when we visit. Don't lead her to places, like dining area, or suggest times for meals or activities. Let her drive and see where it takes you. Spending a whole day might be illuminating. If after several long day visits she seems to be holding her own, then defer the move. They can recommend, but they can't force it.

And NO, moving to MC isn't a death sentence. You need to vet the place first, but as with lealonnie1 and others on this forum, not all MC units are filled with drooling zombies parked in front of a TV. My mother was in one for 4 years, and it was generally a hive of activity.
(1)
Report
Tell them your mom is to stay where she is as ling as she has her mind. If they try to make you put her there anyway, let them know you will be moving your mom.

As you said, she is hard of hearing and seeing, her mind is still there and she shouldn't be moved because she is use to where she is.

My Dad had macula degeneration in both eyes and he took shots once a month for a total of 8 shots and he is now 97 and he can still see enough to get around.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

abkinder: Imho, as you state that your mother suffers from dementia and has been for over a decade, perhaps your dear mother's mind is not as good as you perceive it to be. If the neurologist insists on performing the cognitive test, insist that she needs X10 magnification due to Macular Degeneration in one eye - whehter it be dry or wet, you do not say (the Speech test perhaps is not a written exam?).
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

They are recommending the move, but can't force it. If they haven't given detailed reasons as to why they feel this move is needed, then ask for it.

Testing isn't the whole answer. Some of the questions really don't relate well to every day activities. When's the last time you needed to draw a clock or count backwards by 7s? The younger generation may not even be able to draw clocks, being used to digital! Testing can document changes and progression of memory and/or cognition loss, but most of those tests don't really test day to day activity and ADL abilities.

My mother was still driving despite hearing loss and eyesight damage by MD. She was still able to get by for a while in her own place, despite dementia, but it certainly wasn't safe for her. She was only in the earlier stages, forgetting where she put supplies, what she said 2 minutes about what she asked or what answer you gave 5 minutes ago, but clearly had forgotten how to cook (not a real issue in AL, is it, since they can eat in the main dining area.) Tried to bring in aides, minimally 1hr/day to get her used to them, but she refused to let them in. If you tried to discuss AL with her, it was more like a prison, or a dirt hovel, yet her own plans included AL prior to dementia!

The place chosen was a tear down/rebuild, so we had to get by until they finished and opened MC (it was last of IL/AL/MC to open.) Just days prior to the move, her neighbor reported mom "bruised" her leg. I had no way to get there, but OB was arriving the next evening. I had him check it and send a pic - to the hospital ER ASAP! I had to threaten calling the local ambulance (it was cellulitis, which can kill!) So, she didn't have enough sense to 1) understand how serious this "bruise" was and 2) never told one of us. I'm thankful the neighbor mentioned it, even though she didn't see it.

So, the point here is there may be other issues going on that you aren't aware of/haven't observed. It would be best to get details from staff about their concerns AND spend several days (can be random, not contiguous) ALL day with her to see how she manages. No leading or prompting, give her the "wheel" and let her "drive." If she's truly having issues, she won't be able to "show time" all day every day while you are there.

To repeat myself and others: MC isn't a death sentence, it's just a higher level of care for those who need it. MD and hearing loss are NOT the deciding factors. If they were, my mother would have needed to move to MC LONG before dementia came calling! You can certainly get the testing done, but your best method for aiding the decision is to be there and observe how mom gets through the day, with NO help from you...
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Would she fail if the questions were read to her rather than her having to read them herself. Macular Degeneration as you say does not affect her mind so why do they think she needs more memory care - ask them to explain incidents when there feel there have been cognitive degeneration problems that suggest they can no longer cope with her which cannot be explained by her deteriorating sight. Is her behaviour becoming more frustrated due to the sight loss and they are putting it down to the dementia? That sort of thing. Before moving her I think they need to justify to you why there is a need - you may have to accept it, they may be wrong. Why a speech therapist to do a cognitive test? I do not have experience of this in an elderly person with dementia, but certainly in a much younger relative with macular degeneration I have seen him have to be quite firm with people over the fact he sees less, his brain hasn't gone. Its odd how some people mix one disability in with another.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter