I am in a situation that I am sure is not unique. I am the oldest and I am the only son. I have two sisters and they are as different as night and day. I live about 2 hours away and I have a highly demanding job. I am also the only child that left home after high school and made something of myself and that has led to jealously. I have money because I sacrificed other things so I could have a nice life. Now the issue. I have one sister who goes and visits my parents on Saturday but she cannot take a day off to take them to very important appointments (Dad has cancer and mom has mental health issues). She swears she is doing so much and needs some help. In the mean time, I take vacation days and go up and take the both to most of their more important appointments. I end up having to stay at a hotel because the same sister's son lives with my parents for free and they will not even make him leave so I have a place to stay (he is 21). My other sister, who is sweet, has just come out of an abusive relationship and was abused by both my mom and dad when she was younger. She was the only child left in house because both myself and my other sister had left home. She is the only one of us who actually talks to my mom on the phone. Myself and my other sister just cannot put up with moms BS. My question, is there something wrong with me? Should I expect my sisters to actually help and give up something or should I just accept that I am the only adult and just do it all? It is affecting my health, my relationship with my wife and my job. I am out of vacation time for the year and I have to pretend to be in the office so my dad and mom can go to their appointments. My middle sister is showing all the same signs as my mom from a mental health perspective so maybe I should give her the slack she wants? I am in a pickle.
If your parents are on medicaid, it will be easy to put them in a nursing home with a doctor's order. However, there also may be services Medicaid has to offer like transport. Talk to a social worker.
You and your sister are propping up dependence, not independence. Your sister feels she can’t cope, you and your wife aren’t going well. This will get gradually worse. Where is your father in this? If he is not in intensive cancer care, living with cancer doesn’t mean that he can’t make sensible decisions. Mental illness or not, why is your mother being allowed to call the shots? Because she always has? Are your parents tolerating the nephew to keep your sister in the loop, and your sister is in the loop to provide accommodation for your nephew? When you feel that things are breaking down, you are probably already past the point where change is due.
Perhaps you, your wife and your sister need to talk through what is workable , as suggested already. It would help your marriage to ask for wife about options for change – if you have been resistant to change, you have probably ignored or criticised her comments so far. When you work things out, you present the options to your parents. If they won’t accept any of them, you back off. Wait for the crisis. It could be the only way.
In the meantime, see if you can get the paperwork in order – HIPPA, wills, POA. If your parents won’t co-operate, you have proof positive that you have no power, no rights, no influence, and that you can’t do the ‘safe and happy’ outcome. Back off until something happens to force a change.
Take a breath, get a pen and paper and write down exactly what you are willing to do for your parents that will preserve your family and your sanity. Then ask your sisters the same question and write down their answers. Now, take another page and write down all the things your parents apparently need that they don’t have. That includes legal things like POAs, wills, etc. in addition to home maintenance and health care.
Finally, compare the two lists and the mismatch represents what someone else needs to do. Can these things be done by a home caregiver, an elder attorney, meals on wheels, care transport, etc. or are there other options. See if your sisters will help finding the resources. Then tell your parents exactly what their options are. Let them decide, but stick to your plan. If they refuse, as is their right, and you remain concerned for their welfare, contact Social Services and let the system decide. Even then, don’t let anyone guilt you into sacrificing your life and your family.
And if ur mom n dad own a home in Texas if they get provider services from Disabled Aging n Development DADS they are single and are able to live n keep the home if they are caring for them when they pass. is what I read for a friend of mine.
So have a living will drawn up its ur best option. If ur gonna pay anyone to care hire from a company because family who lives in home definitely needs a break and DADS does offer care to provide family time for themselves. And also can provide daycare like a center for ur mom to go spend time away from home and has shuttle service. They offer discounts as well. Make sure u play nice with mom get her Durable POA especially on financial because u don’t want her to be taking advantage of those not employed or living for free. Have copies of all drs n SSDI n medical and any other things like bills n more be also sent a copy to ur address to make sure nothing is going wrong. I did it with my mom had her credit reporting and more sent to me and found her credit being used and that is fraud. Had a friend who family home was signed over to her provider she had for years literally family wasn’t aware but since she had access to the home n everything inside they changed over the home after dad passed and couldn’t provide proof because all documents were destroyed and document in court files important paperwork. I’m sure I got more info but that’s all I can remember right now. Hopefully I can get a Attorney to open up a certain Circumstance case for my injuries but also I’m hoping to find my Gma because I love her and want her to know that I’m looking for her and I care. Especially because locking the elderly up away from families is wrong even if some people have taken advantage of them like lowlifes but as long as they are not removed from nursing home I see no reason why family can’t visit. I’m not on the side of those cousins n aunts that have taken advantage of her n my mom but I know my Gma and she loves all of us and she never pushed anyone out her life yes she stopped helping them but never stopped caring about them. So it hurts to know she has so much family who would love to buy her food or visit but no one will say anything n have there circle of allowed people. But she had 9kids 1 stepdaughter my mom but my grandpa adopted 5 of her other kids so we definitely are apart of her, I told my sister if mom needs to be in a nursing home I wanna put them together so at least they have eachother but of course my sister won’t go out her way to look for my Gma cuz they were close. N Im working on my SSDI so it’s hard to care for elderly. Please do all that u can pick them up keep them for a weekend I did when my sisters had my mom n dad. But never did they do it for me. It wasn’t fair. Split up chores bill paying groceries shopping drs appts taking care of setting up funeral before death. Take care of wills n trust, deeds, take over payees and have auto drawn rent n bills taken then give weekly allowance to make sure funds last. Birthcet n wills n docs in bank. Or attorney
You certainly cannot handle all of the care needed for your parents alone. There is nothing wrong with your feelings. I highly recommend hiring a caregiver either private or through an agency. They can help and take parents to the many doctor appointments. If HIPPA forms are signed each doctor can communicate freely with you. You cannot make your sisters do more than they are willing. I would expect the grandson living with them to complete a list of household chores or else move. Can the sisters help pay for caregivers or at least have groceries delivered and meals? Ask them to decide how they can help without physically being there.
I am the oldest of four, both brothers estranged from parents, sister critically ill in hospital from covid she had in Dec. I had to hire help but it was still exhausting managing everything. Dad passed but now I used home delivery for everything, groceries, meds and household items.
Please message me and I can give more information.
We live in Jax, Fl.
2012 car accident mri 4 herniated disc 2cervical very minor n 2 in lumber. Many times before my injury I asked my sisters to split up my mom 1week each n I would take her 2 weeks as a set schedule because she wants to be with us all. They denied it. Cancer doesn’t mean he is not able to make decisions. he still might have the power to give u Durable POA especially over himself. ur mom has a mental disability is she mentally capable he might also be able to give u both POA. My Gma had everyone taking advantage of her Goto part 4
**“Durable Power of Attorney”** one for medical and one for other stuff like the homes and banks and more. A Durable Power of Attorney is still valid even after death or coma and dementia. So we were happy with it and my dad was too because he said ur sisters n my son are just gonna lock us up in a nursing home first chance they get. Worked great my mom 2 months later fell hit her head in the middle of the street while visiting my dad at the nursing home diagnosed her with dementia she had brain damage and had to relearn how to do a lot of things. I moved her I. With my middle sister since I had just had a car accident n couldn’t give 100% and I would go to my sis house 7am-6pm to care for my mom she had nights. Dad stayed in nursing home since he was stuck and needed men to help since now his body was curled up n in a wheelchair. Later my sister lost her job n she moved mom with oldest sister I told her to bring her to me but she didn’t listen. So after my dad got worse I was called in to pull the plug and my sisters n stepbrother got a little pissed when they found out about the new POA now he passed away and my oldest sister is leaving my mom home with my cousin who is working as my moms provider service. Red next answer it doesn’t fit.
The American Cancer Society (ACS) has teamed up with Lyft to provide free rides for those battling cancer. It is part of the society's Road To Recovery program. The rides are available to and from treatments and are free of charge, courtesy of ACS. Can you ask the hospital about it or call and maybe there is a local chapter that can help. This should take some stress off.
or https://www.cancer.org/treatment/support-programs-and-services/resource-search.html.
good luck
You are in a tough situation. Some of us are natural caregivers or carry guilt that gets us in these positions. I have felt like I was going out of my mind bc not only was I doing everything, but my 4 sibs, all of whom live out of state, do not support me emotionally at all other than about 5 minutes if that of our bimonthly zooms. We have been a "nice" family and never had any issues, but they simply are not there for me even though I finally came out and directly explained where I was physically and emotionally and that I needed them to call me to support me. They did not and do not respond!!! I then realized that I had a choice to stay on the pity pot and be angry or find my support elsewhere. I am not able to comprehend how they can abandon me other than to believe that they just don't get it. I have wonderful children and friends who are there for me and check in with me often. I am slowly learning to set boundaries with my aunt on my own and to let go of the sense of responsibility I have taken on for her care. Like hiring an agency while she had a terrible uti for a month and was confused. to the point of calling the police at 4am to tell them that I hadn't returned from a walk. Telling her I was no longer going to do all the cleaning, shopping, running, total care of the house. I'm getting there but have a way to go. I'm determined not to cave and to take care of myself. I am also done sending the long reports via text to keep my sibs informed. Not one has checked in for an update. I am working very hard to maintain a good attitude and accept them where they are so that when this is all over we can have a good relationship. It's a delicate balance, isn't it?!
Now I have found this group and feel support already.
Good luck!
During the early days, before and after the move to MC, I got little help from them and a lot of crap. I found myself being angry and after some flak from both, started an email to each, to let them know how hateful and hurtful these things they said were and how having to "do it all" myself was impacting me. I would set these aside, come back later to update/edit, but eventually just left them in the draft folder. I got out what I needed to, and realized sending them would not only fail to improve anything, but would likely put them on the defensive, leading to offensive. So, I let it go. I do what I have to for mom's care and forget them.
*Recent contact with non-local brother's daughter (she's an only), she let me know that she hasn't had contact with him in a long long LONG time! After he was abusive during his last trip to "help", we had discussions and she revealed that she also has been victim to his abuse. I was glad we talked, as I could assure her that it was NOT her fault - this IS who he is! When we were still on okay terms, all I would hear from him was Molly this, Molly that. Molly is his 2nd wife's granddaughter. NOTHING ever about his own daughter. Sad.
BTW, my niece and I are not the only targets. He has no good words for MANY people, co-workers, various doctors and others, who he deems to be idiots. I've heard plenty of his disparagement of others. We just happened to be the only ones who likely dealt with the physical manifestations of his insecurities.
I decided that you may just need a very little support.
I fully support your plan as stated:
" I informed everyone that this trip up tomorrow to take dad to his next procedure is my last for the foreseeable future."
You've got this!
I apologize in advance for not having read the previous responses!
First off, there is nothing wrong with you!!!
It's understandable how you could feel overwhelmed with the situation.
Is it possible for the 21 year old to help with Doctors appointments?
If not, why not try Uber etc...?
There are agencies that will help with transportation for a nominal fee.
The sibling dynamics are extremely difficult!
I can tell you that as the only daughter with 3 brothers, they all thought that I was the chosen one.
In a way, they were right!
What my brothers didn't understand was that I was chosen to be the emotional support dog.
Years of criticism and guilt.
Each of your siblings may have had an entirely different experience growing up!
So please be guick to listen and slow to respond!
My point is that you have practical solutions!
Before you let this situation tear your family apart, search for those solutions.
Wishing you all the best!!
Expecting siblings to help or chip in more isn't likely to change anything either. Certainly sister who has been abused shouldn't be expected to do anything. Any wonder why she ended up in an abusive relationship? Look no further than her upbringing! The other sister, showing signs similar to mom, let them work it out between them! Even the 21 yo isn't likely to step up - why should he? He's living there scot-free now, he's not likely to change now. You can ask or even demand he take on some role in their care, but I wouldn't hold my breath! You really can't force anyone else to do anything.
Your mother rules the roost, and won't pay for help. Well, when she's no longer getting her expected "free" help, she'll have to do something. She will likely ramp up demands, so you'll have to stay strong. Don't bother making any excuses, real or not, they just provide fodder for her next attack. Simple no. If she repeats, she gets a second no. If she goes for the trifecta or "hat trick", hang up. She sounds very domineering and strong willed, so be prepared for call back - don't answer. Let it go to voicemail. Given enough times, she will likely figure it out.
While it's clear dad would need medical appointments, possible on a regular basis due to the cancer, what exactly are mom's needs? You mention you "take the both to most of their more important appointments." What are her issues, above and beyond mental health? Do either of them drive? Depending on your relationship with your dad (is it better or the same as with mom?), I might be willing to help him out, but rather than jeopardizing your job or marriage, I'd figure the cost of gas, wear and tear on oneself and the car and the cost of the hotel and might find that paying for transport (only his! let mom fend for herself!) would be less expensive and certainly less time consuming. Your own mental health will benefit from this too!
Agreed it is something THEY should pay for themselves, but IF and ONLY IF my relationship with dad was okay would I consider paying if mom refuses to pay. His treatments are likely very important, so if all else fails he could at least get there and back. It might help take a little "guilt" off you if you could provide that - but again, it is highly dependent on how you feel about him and whether it is important enough to ensure he gets treatments. Mom may reject them as well, when they show up to drive dad.
Definitely stick with that back off plan. IF she ever "comes to her senses" and realizes she needs to be nicer to get you back, weigh each request carefully. NO is a complete sentence. Use it if you must! You still have the final say. Send a list of numbers for drivers/taxis/community vans.
Literally if need be.
Stop helping them before you ruin your life. They're not your problem and certainly not something you should be spending any of your money on. They can take an Uber to a Dr appt.
There are so many good folks on the forum that have walked in your shoes, so please reach out and stay connected to the caring people that can give you suggestions and encouragement!!! Liz
Most important human relationship - your marriage. Don't jeopardize what you have with your spouse with overwhelming responsibilities to others. Your spouse will feel neglected and the stress will bleed into this relationship.
Second most important relationship - family. Put parents and siblings on the same level of priority. Only your children will be higher in importance than parents and sibs - but always lower than spouse.
Since your parents' needs are more than any of you can handle alone, it is time for a family conference. Decide with your siblings if your parents are safe to be alone. If not, they need companions to be there all the time. Also decide if your parents' health is being adequately maintained. With a cancer diagnosis and a mental health challenge, it may be time for changes. Hire help to do the driving to and from appointments (sometimes cities and counties have special public transportation to handle this). Get more people involved in caring for your parents: family, friends, members of faith community and/or paid help. Lastly, consider that your parents' health challenges may require full time residential care: round the clock home health aides (least expensive), assisted living, or full care residential facility (most expensive). Whichever route you, your parents' resources should pay for their own care. If there is insufficient resources, talk to social work where dad is getting treatment for their help.
This sounds too similar to the situation I was in with my wife and her need to caregive for her parents. Her brothers and sister and her Mother took full advantage of the situation and it eventually cost us our marriage.
Your issues here cannot get answered in one of these boxes.
Based on your description you are in a highly disfuntional, family. Unfortunatly your not alone. In order for your marriage and successful life you are building to survive do not be suprised if you end up breaking away from these people.
I mean this sincerely. You should stop after you read this. Sit down with your wife, the two of you find someone NOW to help you manuever thru this mine field (family) your in. I urge you to find a therapist or a clergy if you are active in a church. All the dynamics you have here can't be figured out in one of these response boxes. Check your health insurance at work it will most likely pay for some or all of the therapy.
I suggest some books:
The seven habits of highly effective families by Steven Covey
Seven Principles for making a Marriage Work Dr John Gottman
Boundaries by Dr Henry Cloud& Dr Henry Townsend
Tough times dont last tough, tough people do. Rev Robert Shuller
Don't You know who I am. Ramani Durvasula Phd
Depending on how much damage this has done to your Marriage (you may not even know how much harm has been done) there is a marriage strengthing program called Retrouvaille www.helpourmarriage.org. It is operated by the Catholic Church The actual program is conducted entirely by couples.
I urge to not ignore this. Take action now. Things WILL NOT get better. Your family will not suddenly start being respectful of you and your Marriage.
Best of Success
Thank you for replying to my earlier comment. I wanted to reply to it here, instead of replying to my own comment.
When I mentioned layers of dysfunction I was speaking from experience. My parents were well respected public figures to a degree in my small community, as well Dad was a high school teacher. He very much was a know it all and very full of himself. Mum was an active volunteer and highly regarded too. There were often in the local paper. I was considered to be a problem child because I rebelled against the abuse at home. Oh it was mostly not physical, there were few visible bruises on my skin, by my soul was damaged by decades of emotional abuse.
I have been chastened by some here for my strong stance on maintaining boundaries and not providing hands on care. I have been accused of not loving my parents, but in fact, I have learned to love and value myself.
It took thousands of dollars and hours of therapy to get to where I am now. And you know what? I am confident that the choices I have made are the best for me. Who else is going to look out for me?
Mum has stopped whining to me about not having any money, because each time she did, I reminded her she has a house worth over $300K, if she sold it at age 86, she has more than enough money to keep her going.
You need to not be available as much. I would just say I cant do it. Imp meetings I cant take time off. You can't loose your job in covid times. That is paramount. Better yet say you cant do it.. when they demand an explanation they dont have a right to one. No is a complete answer. Too bad if they whine and they will.
You keep stepping up so they keep backing off, acting incompetent, need to do something else etc.
And you cant do the hotel any more, it puts you at massive corona virus risk from mult strangers in and around the hotel and the room. They dont clean all surfaces. You could get it and give it to dad. You need your health too. You have to keep your job in these times. Corona virus is going up and up so you can't risk your parents. Your staying home. Your staying put. End of story.
If a doc appt passes without them picking up the slack so be it. They will see you are serious. They won't as long as they can keep pretending to flounder in incompetence.
You need to back off. Miss phone calls. Miss frantic dad/mom need help! What are we to do? We cant do it. Being more demanding they help, wont get you anywhere. Not stepping up will. You still can help. but every 2-3rd time. You are being competent so they don't have to. Your not even poa so stop it. Dont be surprised when daughter and son demand the house they are living in later.
You need to back off and not run every time parents need something.
I have a friend who had cancer. I dont know if everyone can get this, but she had a van come pick her up for all her treatments. Maybe you can look into that. Cant dad be more proactive in his care with the care team? Call hospital ask doc or social worker. If you cant. Then someone else can do it. Tell doc you just can't keep this up. They need to call the residence. Not you. Your stretched too thin. Take your name off as contact info.! That will be hard but do it. Your going to have to be on pins/needles till they get off their butts and help.
Remember you can't call them for a few days after they call. They will be frantic to get you to keep stepping up, and handle whatever it is. You are now unavailable. Thats all they need to know. Never ever go into to lengthy explanations. They dont need to know, or have the right to demand. Or criticize. They criticize, you are unavailable even longer.
Or say mom has made it impossible to help so your letting her step up now. Do not be available! Dont be surprised when you back off, there will be mult emergencies, and melt downs. It will be on purpose. Dont be surprised if they say they have covid, if the house is about to burn down, if dad has no one, their throwing up, he's missed 5 appts etc.
Dont answer phone for at least 48hrs.
If it was an emergency then they are closer to handle it. You know they can handle it, they dont want to. Get a back bone and dont let them walk all over you. It is not your job to fix others and their personalities. Get your name off the primary contact. it goes to their house now. Good luck
Repeat this information to the doctor her/himself, that your parents HAVE resources but refuse to use them and that YOU will be stepping away.
It is so hard, an almost impossible task to back away.
There are caregivers speaking to you who have had successes.
Unless you choose the emergency 'no contact' method to save yourself
(not advocating that --in your father's condition/cancer), this will be a battle for you.
I would like to suggest that you can educate yourself more about boundaries and narcissism (being careful not to hate the person, just the behaviors) and you can gain helpful techniques once aware of how you get sucked in and stuck.
How can this all be your fault? I am not seeing it. Not your fault.
Try not giving the narcissist information or announcing what you are planning too far in advance. [Tell the doctor at his appointment that he won't have care, but needs it. The doctor is always the one to order the care needed.]
Announcing your plans to the narcissist gives them time to twist things, forcing you to give in and change your mind. Example: " I informed everyone that this trip up tomorrow to take dad to his next procedure is my last for the foreseeable future." With that as ammo, your mother could create a crisis.
Try small changes, until you can effect changes. For example, have Dad schedule appointments for a Friday afternoon when you may be able to take off work earlier without consequences. As opposed to when Mom and Dad make the appointments. If you are going to be taking Dad at all.
The call made to the Area Agency on Aging did not go well for you. Do not give up. Call back, explain or ask: "You want to talk to the people so in need of help they cannot help themselves?". Ask them if they recommend you call APS because they will be without resources if AAA cannot help. Most people start with having meals on wheels delivered, puts a visual on their problems by an outside source. I was told that, knowing what the agencies have available to help is better than going in blind needing help, because they do not offer you a menu of available resources. An outside housekeeper can observe and report, confirm areas of need if you can get one coming in.
Each time you 'consult' a dysfunctional family member about what can be done, it is going to be like receiving darts aimed at that balloon of hope you keep trying to inflate, over and over again. Focus on what you can and are willing to do, just between you and your Dad if you are doing it for Dad.
Try saying "No" to your Mom, more and more. She has no need to be in charge of his appointment. Leave her at home, as she needs a break.
Take anything that I have said, and if possible, apply it to your situation. I know the details are not perfect or foolproof. I am understanding that you may not be able to just go 'no contact'. My sympathies.
Last note:
It is unrealistic and not sustainable to drive 2 hours, stay in a hotel, to take your father to his appointments. Been there, done that. But family will allow it! Absurd.
That leaves a huge budget for hiring a driver (ask AAA), whether you are paying or Mom is paying. Mom should be paying. But this could be part of your back-away plan, to hire a driver privately. imo.