My brother has COPD and is 100% disabled according to the VA. My dad is on Hospice care with CHF. I have been the primary caregiver for the past four years and now I need some back up. I'm 73, he's 53. He claims he can't "breathe" at dad's house because it's too "stuffy". He wouldn't do any heavy lifting, just helping with daily chores. We have a cleaning person every two weeks, and I stay on top of everything from dispensing meds, meal prep, laundry, etc. My husband's health is failing, and I need to be home more, besides being exhausted, and need to slow down a bit. My sister makes dad breakfast five days a week,
Brother has never been hospitalized for COPD, not on oxygen, and uses an inhaler. He doesn't do much at home other than watch TV in his recliner most of the day. I think this is more probably by design than necessity. As far as dad's home being "stuffy", the rooms are large, and the house is clean. Everyone else is comfortable there. I just need to know if he's being overly dramatic and lazy or if I should be more empathetic? He's just never been known for putting himself out for anyone.
Edit: Your Dad needs more help.
This does not mean your brother needs to provide it.
He said no.
He doesn’t have to give a reason.
Hands-on caregiving is not for everyone.
Consider a family meeting with all the key support people. Discuss with honesty with Dad, what Dad's care needs now are. Compare to what family can do. Include who wants to do more, who wants to do less, how to add more help, who will provide the additional help.
He has a cleaning service. Good.
Most families reach a point that more NON-family help is needed.
Dad may be there.
Forget about your brother! You and your sister need to have a serious conversation about your dad, whose needs are only going to increase. If you're 73 then your father is probably 90-something years old? How big is his house? What kind of shape is it in? What are his finances like? Can he afford to hire in-home help? What about assisted living? Do you or your sister have durable power of attorney?
If you want to help your father then start with the essentials - food, shelter, activities of daily living - and leave your brother out of it because he doesn't want to help and any help you get from him will either be short-lived, awful, or both.
Your father deserves dignity at his age. And it sounds like only you and your sister are interested in preserving that for him.
Stop expecting him to now be someone he never was.
Expectations = premeditated disappointments
He's a taker. Not a giver.
Hire help with dad's money. Brother is who he is
"Everyone else is comfortable at dad's house" because they don't have debilitating respiratory conditions! The slightest thing can set off a person with COPD that a healthy person wouldn't even notice.
Hire in home help as needed and don't insist on getting blood from a stone.
Good luck to you.
So he can not be your “ backup “ that you are looking for. Either hire help with Dad’s money or place Dad in a facility so you can focus on your husband .
I personally think that if we make the choice to do caregiving we have no right whatsoever to expect it of others.
I think no one here would be comfortable judging your brother.
When you yourself, who have known him a lifetime, are uncertain whether he is telling the truth or not, how could we, a bunch of strangers from round the world, have a better guess?
He also won't be their 'employee' & be rostered by them.
He offers to do other tasks as befit his ability & apptitude.
He has seen, as I have, that the family-must-help-family ideal is a wonderful value but can get skewed into Family-Only-must-help-family. That is impractical.
Even if your brother was well, would you really want someone who doesn’t want to be a caregiver doing this work?
I wouldn’t want someone who wasn’t interested in helping because they would become to extremely resentful and not care for your mom properly.
Wishing you all the best.
See All Answers