Follow
Share

Family doesn't want their Dad to lose his license. They won't listen to my observations, nor to the report from the OT. He did well in written work, but very slow reaction time in other tests. Seems unaware of one-way streets, speed limit signs, drives too fast or too slow. Poor lane placement, etc. I am the bad guy when I try to explain his bad driving habits to them. What should I do?

So the "children" are in denial that dad has Alzheimer's, meaning he's perfectly fine to drive, and potentially kill YOU, their mother, himself and innocent people out in their cars including children?????

In the book, Understanding the Dementia Experience by Jennifer Ghent-Fuller on Amazon, the author devotes a section to driving. She told her husband, little by little, that SHE would drive, to please sit in the passenger seat. In short order, she took over driving entirely and the husband didn't even question it. Pick up a few copies of that book for your own children. Denial is not just a river in Egypt.

I personally wouldn't let my husband drive at ALL if he's "unaware of one-way streets, speed limit signs, drives too fast or too slow. Poor lane placement, etc." Lose the keys or insist on driving yourself. Be the Bad Guy for everyone's sake, someone MUST BE. especially in the case of dementia. And why, pray tell, do your children get to weigh in on such decisions at all? Really, unless they are doing the 24/7 hands on caregiving and dealing with the ins and outs of all this, they GET no say!

Wishing you the best of luck taking the bull by the horns and corralling all of the trouble makers into the barn!
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report
Dawn88 May 14, 2024
Love it!
(0)
Report
The "family" needs to get over themselves. As the WIFE, you run the show.
If they aren't doing Dad's daily caregiving, they have NO SAY.

Tell them this:
You aren't the "bad guy" by preventing deadly accidents to innocent people.
You are the SHERO.

You have enough to deal with doing Dad's caregiving. Like Alva says, tell them to "Hush up and mind their own business." PERIOD.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Dawn88
Report

YOU are the one that rules the roost at this point.
Tell the kids if they want to continue to let him drive THEY can move him into their house, use one of their cars and put him on their insurance.
Tell them that you are not going to shoulder the burden WHEN he gets into an accident and the reports WILL show that he has been told to "limit" his driving due to a diagnosis of dementia and poor performance on the driving test.
(frankly I would put a total ban on his driving)

If this makes you a "bad guy" then I wish there were more "bad guys" doing the same thing.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report

This doesn’t seem like “early” Alzheimer’s. More like mid-stage, but that’s beside the point.

Ever heard of a wrongful death suit? That’s a thing where you and your husband can potentially lose everything you’ve worked for and own. Both of you, even if he’s the driver. It would certainly be brought up in court that you knew he had Alzheimer’s and took no measures to stop him from driving. Vehicular homicide is not something that law enforcement tends to overlook.

Here and in real life, I’ve really learned to dislike “the kids want this,” or “the kids say that.” Why on earth does anyone think they have to do what their kids want, especially when they’re adults and out of the house? As a parent of adult kids, I just don’t get it. I do what I want and they do what they want, and we’re all happy with that arrangement.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
AlvaDeer May 14, 2024
I so agree. The kids are not an issue here unless allowed to be one. This needs to be a case of the right thing needing to be done. Period. Or live with the consequences which well may be dire.
(6)
Report
Montana Motor Vehicle Form 32-1800 -Recommendation for Re-Examination

Available online. Get a copy of the doctors diagnosis attach it. Include everything in your original post that you have observed.

An OT is not a medical doctor and most doctors do not want to say if someone is capable of driving in writing. (been there, done that) They will give a proper medical diagnosis but not include if they can or cannot drive or play the violin.

Driving is a privilege not a right and a degenerating brain does not understand this. Sometimes a full functioning brain does not understand this. It is irrelevant what the kids or anyone else thinks but it is understandable to desire a united front backing up your decision.

We are all here backing you up with our collective experiences.

Went thru this with my father, had lots of unsolicited advice and remarks how terrible this was to "do-to-HIM". My retort would be -I am not loading a gun and handing it to HIM when he is angry, nor am I letting him drive when he is not in capacity to do it.

The DMW process took a while but it was then up to the state agency and him. The agency got the blame not me.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to CourageousKid
Report
AlvaDeer May 15, 2024
This is great information for our OP! Thank you.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Something. Anything. He needs to be off the roads NOW.

I live in an over-55 community where these people are all over the place. They run into things and people and over plants and into store windows. They run stop signs, speed, and ignore flashing lights at crosswalks where pedestrians are passing. No effort is made to get them of the roads by either police or the community.

Bad things happen. My neighbor almost sideswiped a stop sign on the other side of the street because she never stays in her lane when she makes the left hand turn. It made tire tacks on the adjacent lawn. I was watching and it was scary. Someday a person will be there walking her dog and Mrs. Redvan may run over both of them.

Ask the family if they are okay with losing their dad or possibly having to deal with the lawsuits against him, after he kills or injures someone. He could lose everything he has in a lawsuit. OOPS - there goes their inheritance!
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
Dogwood63 May 14, 2024
"Ask the family if they are okay with losing their dad or possibly having to deal with the lawsuits against him, after he kills or injures someone. He could lose everything he has in a lawsuit. OOPS - there goes their inheritance!" <-- This!
(3)
Report
Stop talking to them and take his dl away. It’s none of their business and they don’t get a vote.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Southernwaver
Report

Oh please, why on earth are the children opposed to their father losing his license? Would they rather him lose his life or cause someone else to lose theirs?

My youngest brother has been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s disease at age 60. One of the first things that I told him was to stop driving!

My brother had several accidents. His doctors have told him that his driving days are over. His doctors also told him that he can no longer fly alone. He was getting lost in the airport.

My brother was saying that he only had to be “more mindful.” There is no way that he can be “more mindful” because he is living with an incurable, progressive disease.

It is hard to see someone losing their independence but everyone involved must adapt to facing the truth. It is counterproductive for this family to feel as if their father can continue driving.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to NeedHelpWithMom
Report

Is there any chance that your husband would VOLUNTARILY stop driving if you seriously asked him to? That would render the kids' opinions null and void--which they need to be anyway. My husband (94 Y/O) stopped driving in 2020. He's a former athlete and was a police officer many years ago so has always been healthy, strong and fit. However, we're both old-old now. Four years ago, he realized that his short-term memory, vision and physical abilities weren't what they once were and accepted that he needed to stop driving completely. (He had already given up night and out-of-area driving some years earlier.)

I'm 87 and still drive locally during the daytime. I drive my small manual-shift SUV safely with self-imposed limitations. (So far, I've had no tickets, accidents, close calls or near misses). Admittedly I dread the day when I can no longer drive to the grocery store, but I hope/think I will know when/if that time has arrived.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to ElizabethAR37
Report
AlvaDeer May 14, 2024
I stopped years ago. I think my Mom plowing into the Nursery and destroying all those trees (rather than people) was a lesson to me. We made certain to live where we have transit. I never was a special driver so drove little and that of course makes you more tentative, and a worse driver without strong instinctual reflexes. I had a vitreous separation in my right eye which took vision down in that eye, and tho eye doc assured me I could still pass I felt I should no longer drive. I am 81. Gave up my license a decade ago.
(3)
Report
See 3 more replies
Patty, some of the early answers think this is YOUR father, so perhaps confirm that it’s your husband, the kids’ father. Does he have a POA? If not, he is at the stage where it can probably still be organised. If he nominates one of the kids, make sure that it not someone who is pushing for him to drive.

One way to deal with this is to type out an ‘agreement’ for each child to sign, agreeing that they will pay for all and any damages that result from a vehicle accident involving their father as a driver. One for each child. Make it as formal as possible, dated and witnessed. My experience is that signing something like that sets people back on their heels. At the moment it's all a bit abstract. Making it very personal also makes it very different.

If they won’t sign (and they won’t if they have half a brain) you can then have a different conversation about why your own finances can potentially be badly affected but they won’t risk their own money. Let them argue about it between themselves, not with you. It's even worth paying a lawyer to prepare the agreement if you don't feel able to, and getting the kids to sign it with the lawyer's staff as witnesses. Just saying that's what you are going to do may tip the balance.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
pattypk May 15, 2024
Yes, the first word in initial statement is "HUSBAND"..... so don't know why the misunderstanding. No POA yet, but daughter will be Executor, and she seems to be the main one in denial. I am working on getting my husband to voluntarily give up driving.
(3)
Report
See 4 more replies
See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter